Since YouGraduatedExplore Timeline
DisprovedChanged1990

Marie Antoinette said 'let them eat cake'

The old claim turned out to be wrong and was rejected by evidence.

TaughtTold that the peasants had no bread, Queen Marie Antoinette replied "let them eat cake," a remark whose cruelty helped ignite the French Revolution.

NowThere is no evidence she ever said it. The line appears in Rousseau's Confessions, written around 1765, describing an unnamed "great princess," when Marie Antoinette was a nine-year-old child in Austria who had never set foot in France.

What actually happened

Rousseau's phrase is "qu'ils mangent de la brioche," and brioche is enriched bread rather than cake, which matters because the original jab was about an aristocrat who could not conceive of a household without a bread cupboard. Rousseau attributes it to no one in particular, and the anecdote was already a stock story about out-of-touch nobility before her birth.

It was pinned to her later. Revolutionary pamphleteers ran a sustained campaign against the foreign queen, producing pornographic libels and invented quotations, and "let them eat cake" was attached to her by the 1840s, decades after her execution. Historians including Antonia Fraser have noted that the sentiment contradicts her documented behavior: her letters show awareness of the bread crisis, and she funded charities during food shortages.

She remains a fair subject of criticism as a symbol of Versailles extravagance during a fiscal catastrophe. But the single most-quoted sentence of her life is one she did not say, and the correction has been standard in the scholarship for a long time.

Newsletter

Get new weekly revisions

Join 3,821 readers

Sources

  1. Encyclopaedia Britannica: Did Marie-Antoinette Really Say 'Let Them Eat Cake'?britannica.com
  2. Smithsonian Magazine: Marie Antoinettesmithsonianmag.com

Who was taught this

Still standard through 2005, so anyone who finished school between 1950 and 1990 learned the earlier version.